Submitted by Ben Bache on

American Apostasy

As you’ve undoubtedly heard by now, the 2026 midterm election is being termed a “blue tsunami,” with Democrats racking up significant victories at all levels of government. Democrats flipped Senate seats in Iowa, Kansas, Maine, Mississippi, North Carolina, Ohio, South Carolina, and Texas. As of this writing, Democrats will have 55 Senate seats in the new Congress, with Alaska officially undecided (although Democrat Mary Peltola the likely winner). Democrats last won a Senate seat in North Carolina in 2008; Mississippi’s Scott Colom is the first black US Senator since Reconstruction, and the first Democratic Senator in 44 years. In Maine Republicans had held the Senate seat formerly occupied by Susan Collins for 30 years. No Democrat has held a Senate seat from Kansas since 1932. The last time Democrats had a majority at least this size in the Senate was in 2014, when they held 55 seats.

In the House, Democrats look to be on their way to the largest majority since 2008. As of this writing the AP Election Hub shows them with 256 seats, with approximately 8 seats still undecided. Projections vary, but Democrats are generally expected to emerge with a total of approximately 260 seats in the House, the most since the 1974 election in the Watergate era.

The election also brought a number of other “firsts.”1

Meanwhile, exit polls from NBC and CNN both showed Republicans losing support among Catholics and religiously unaffiliated voters, although analysts ascribed the shift largely to economic factors. Amid the history making, however, one factor remained relatively constant. Approximately 82% of white evangelical voters polled expressed support for Trump – nearly identical to the support from that group reported in CNN’s exit poll in the 2024 presidential election. Preliminary results suggest more evangelical voters sat out this election than previously, however, although that could be an attribute of the midterm vs. presidential election. The NBC poll found 17% of respondents identifying as White born-again or evangelical Christians, down from 23% in 2024. White evangelical support for Trump as measured by the midterm voter exit polls was higher, percentage-wise, than was reported in an April 2025 Pew Research Center poll, which found support for his job performance at 72%, and his actions regarding DEI programs at 75%.

A survey by the nonprofit Kettering Foundation conducted in the spring of 2026 found approximately 30% of the US population enthusiastic about or sympathetic with Christian nationalism. Over half of self-identified Republicans belonged to this category.

Indiana University’s Andrew L. Whitehead has identified five elements that define the “Christianity” in Christian Nationalism:

  • Desire for a “Traditional Social Hierarchy” in which “men lead while women support, marriage is reserved for men and women, only two genders are recognized, children are raised in homes with their biological mother and father, and families commit to having large families.”
  • A preference for white, natural-born citizens. Whitehead notes that this assumes a historical narrative in which these were the people who created the country, and hence are the group that should “enjoy the easiest access to civil rights, social benefits, and political power.” Conversely, racial and ethnic diversity are regarded as signs of weakness.
  • An idealized free-market capitalism emphasizing privatization, deregulation, and reduced public spending. Each American is “personally responsible for their own economic situation.” This, Whitehead notes, “obscure[s] policies that protected the fortunes of the already wealthy,” and limits opportunities for racial and ethnic groups that are the subjects of “legalized discrimination.”
  • A preference for authoritarianism, to preserve “God-ordained hierarchies, boundary-lines, and social systems….” Failure to abide by these structures risks losing divine blessing, so even democracy can’t stand in the way.
  • Populism (right wing) – essentially the idea that the nation was created for common people, and that “elites” are working to steal the commoners’ birthright. Whitehead observes that this leads to a victim mentality, which in turn promotes “antiestablishment politics” and conspiratorial thinking.

Several of these items can be found in the infamous Project 2025 document, which has been described as a “path to Christian nationalism.” The Heritage Foundation, which produced it, counts among its organizational supporters numerous organizations whose explicit purpose is promoting one or more tenets of Christian nationalism. Project 2025 contributors who joined the Trump II administration include: Tom Homan, “border czar”; Brendan Carr, FCC Chair; John Ratcliffe, CIA Director; Peter Navarro, Senior Counselor for Trade and Manufacturing; and many others.

Perhaps the most notable Project 2026 contributors in the second Trump administration are Stephen Miller and Russell Vought.

Miller served as Trump’s deputy chief of staff for policy in the second Trump administration, and was recently appointed chief of staff. Miller is founder and president of America First Legal, which has initiated lawsuits “challenging efforts to remedy racial disparities, support LGBTQ+ students, and to expand early voting.” As his Wikipedia entry notes, “Miller is of Ashkenazi Jewish descent. His family escaped Russian pogroms and the Holocaust.” Observers have noted the irony of Miller’s anti-immigrant policies in the context of his extended family history. Also, Miller has been termed a “white nationalist,” on the assumption that “Christian” would not apply, despite the overlap of policy objectives with Christian nationalism.

Vought, who is a self-identified Christian nationalist, is director of the federal Office of Management and Budget – a position he also held in the first Trump administration. Vought wrote the second chapter of Project 2025’s Mandate for Leadership on the Executive Office of the President, which warns of the supposed danger of a federal bureaucracy “carrying out its own policy plans and preferences—or, worse yet, the policy plans and preferences of a radical, supposedly ‘woke’ faction of the country.”

The Kettering Foundation survey found that 64% of those who enthusiastically embrace Christian nationalism (labeled “Ambassadors” in the survey results) were worried “a great deal” about “[p]eople who are ineligible to vote casting ballots in US elections.2” Conversely, less than a third of “Ambassadors” were worried “a great deal” about “People being harmed by federal agents, military, or law enforcement during peaceful protests.”

In his recent book Backslide, Public Religion Research Institute’s (PRRI) Robert P. Jones calls the “Christian” aspect of Christian nationalism apostasy. Recalling his own upbringing in white evangelical Christian churches in the South, he declares that religion to be lacking in the kind of love “that Jesus showed that crossed the boundaries of race, class, gender, and social.” White evangelical Christians, Jones observes, have “quarantined” their theological beliefs, “shielding them from moral interrogation.”

This protection of theology from morality is usually justified with two theological affirmations: (1) that human beings are living in a fallen state of sinfulness, which has damaged our moral faculties; and (2) its corollary, that God’s ways are far beyond our limited comprehension. Faced with a conflict between theology and morality, white evangelicals have asserted that the safest response is to sacrifice morality, comforting themselves that the conflict is only apparent.

Jones calls “the denial of the role of human faculties in grasping theological truth … the primary portal through which the basest human prejudices of powerful people, usually straight white men in positions of authority, are smuggled into Christianity.”

It is this epistemological maneuver, Jones suggests, that has recently led to what he calls “a dangerous war on what has long been acknowledged as a foundational moral sentiment within Christianity and a civic virtue within pluralistic democracies: the idea of empathy.”

The journal BioPsychoSocial Medicine3 defines empathy as “a multidimensional construct to account for the sense of sharing and understanding of the subjective experience of others.” Behavior associated with social engagement “has been linked to the evolution of the autonomic nervous system and how it relates to emotion.” University of North Carolina psychologist Stephen W. Porges has suggested that empathy is related to the “implicit computation of feelings of safety, comfort, or potential danger.” He has posited that the capacity for empathy and the “establishment of lasting social bonds” arise in the course of the evolution of the autonomic nervous system, and contribute to the adaptive response of an organism.

These brain systems are genetically hard-wired to enable animals to respond unconditionally to threatening or appetitive stimuli using specific response patterns that are most adaptive to the particular species and environmental condition.

Like other species, humans are able to share feelings between individuals, but humans also have a capacity to intentionally “’feel for’ and act on behalf of other people whose experiences may differ greatly from their own.” And unlike other primates, humans “can put their emotions into words, allowing them not only to express emotion but also to report on current as well as past emotions.” This ability to “share, explain, and regulate emotional experience” is not found in other species. Conversation can facilitate the sharing of experience and and feelings, including self-reflection – a capability that “may be an important difference between humans and other species.”

In Backslide Jones locates the origin of what he calls the “evangelical war on empathy” in 2019 writings and presentations by Joe Rigney, a Minneapolis pastor and former president of the conservative, evangelical Bethlehem Seminary. As Jones recounts, Rigney’s theory is that empathy “corrupts,” indulging those the empathizer perceives as victims “without regard for whether such indulgence is wise or prudent or good for them.” Jones notes that Rigney’s examples of such corruption all derive from progressive politics, and especially issues of homosexuality and gender. Moreover, Rigney describes progressive politics as “a culture of victimhood flowing from toxic female empathy.” True Christians, Rigney asserts, must demonstrate the manly virtue of rationality.

The notion of empathy as “dangerous and sinful for Christians” was presented to a wider audience in 2025 when “media personality” Allie Beth Stuckey published her book Toxic Empathy: How Progressives Exploit Christian Compassion. A passage from Stuckey’s book that Jones highlights:

Empathy has been hijacked for the purpose of conforming well-intentioned people to particular political agendas. Specifically, it’s been co-opted by the progressive wing of American society to convince people that the progressive position is exclusively one of kindness and morality.

As Jones describes it, Stuckey’s view of love rejects the Golden Rule and what he calls “Jesus’s examples of service to others,” and dismisses others’ judgments about “what is good or right or true.” “To love,” Stuckey writes, “means to want what is best for a person as God defines best.” A question Stuckey never addresses, Jones notes, is who gets to speak for God?

Like Rigney and other white evangelical elites, Stuckey writes as if two things are simultaneously true: that God’s universal truths can be read directly off the pages of the Bible and that these received truths magically map, without exception, onto the conservative political worldview they happen to hold.

Jones notes the long tradition that this self-deception is part of, reaching back at least to 1845 when members of the Southern Baptist Convention asserted that enslaving blacks was God’s way, and therefore the church’s way. (The denomination apologized for its position in 1995 and now includes congregations that are majority non-white.)

The title of Jones’ book, Backslide, is taken from a term coined by Scottish clergyman, John Knox. In Knox’s An Admonition to the Professors of God’s Truth in England, published in 1545, he is grappling with the observation that it is seldom that something regarded as a work of God “for the comfort of his church” does not bring “trouble, fear, and labor … upon such as God has used for his workmen.” Similarly, he observes, “tribulation most commonly follows that church where Christ Jesus is most truly preached.” In context, Knox is urging his readers to “keep the faith,” in the knowledge that neither fear, nor danger, nor doubt, nor “backsliding” can destroy faith in what he terms “God’s elect.” Rather there will always be some root and spark of faith, “howbeit in their anguish they neither feel nor can discern the same.”

Jones recounts that as a Southern Baptist youth his fear of backsliding was about wanting to live a life of service to the world “rather than being consumed by the empty pursuit of things of the world.” He writes that he was terrified by “the destination to which unchecked backsliding ultimately leads: apostasy….” – the phenomenon he now sees in the “Christian” in Christian nationalism. “[T]he thing about the state of apostasy,” Jones writes, “is that it’s hard to recognize when one has reached it.” Within the self-identified Christian community, in any case, he warns, “the term apostasy should be used with some care,” noting that it has been used to justify “countless acts of reprehensible violence: the Crusades, the Inquisition, witch trials.” Properly understood, he continues, it is a warning.

In the current political environment, Jones writes, he is moved to use terms such as backsliding and apostasy to “help describe the indefensible willingness of white Christians to shed their core values like inconvenient loads along the road to supporting Donald Trump.” He concludes his opening chapter:

I don’t hold out much hope that what passes for religion today among the two-thirds of white Christians who voted for Trump is redeemable. That world is now marked by a shockingly impoverished relationship to the Bible and an outright abandonment of a genuine search for truth. But I’m not writing for those who have fully given themselves over to the spirit of white chosenness, supremacy, and dominion. I’m writing to mark some waypoints for those who know, and those who are waking up to realize, that the foundations of both our politics and our faith need redemption.

In that context, there’s cause for hope in the events that led to the AP’s November 6 headline “Democratic candidates with a Christian message help flip Congress.” The AP refers to “the strength of the religious left as a counter to the stalwart evangelical support for President Donald Trump and his fellow Republicans.” Progressive Baptist pastor Brian Kaylor termed it a repudiation of the evangelical attempt to “corner the market” on Christianity.

In addition to seminarian James Talarico and megachurch pastor Adam Hamilton, Iowa ministers Sarah Trone Garriott, a Lutheran, and Lindsay James, a Presbyterian flipped seats in the House and Senate, respectively. At the same time, at least 7 in 10 “nonreligious” voters supported Democratic congressional candidates in Texas, Kansas, and Iowa, according to the AP Voter Poll.

In his acceptance speech, Talarico drew an explicit contrast to the xenophobic rhetoric that pervades the Christian right, Recounting that his grandfather, a Baptist minister, referred to Jesus as a “barefoot rabbi,” Talarico declared:

Two thousand years ago, when the people at the top hurt his neighbors, that barefoot rabbi didn’t stay in his room and pray. He walked into the seat of power, and he flipped over the tables of injustice. … [I]t’s time to start flipping tables.


  1. First black female governor, Keisha Lance Bottoms; first Muslim Senator, Abdul El-Sayed; first Latina Governor of Texas, Gina Hinojosa; first female Native American Governor, Deb Haaland; first openly gay man elected to the US Senate, Chris Pappas; first Native American woman elected to the Senate, Peggy Flanagan; first Black Governors of Wisconsin (David Crowley), Nevada (Aaron Ford), and Florida (Byron Donalds – a Republican exception to the firsts list); first female governors of Ohio (Amy Acton), Minnesota (Amy Klobuchar), and Tennessee (Marsha Blackburn, Republican).↩︎
  2. Analysis by the American Immigration Council of the Heritage Foundation’s database of so-called “voter fraud” found a total of 68 proven cases since 2000, or less than 0.0001% of total votes.↩︎
  3. BioPsychoSocial Medicine is the official journal of the Japanese Society of Psychosomatic Medicine, exploring links between biological, psychological, social, and behavioral health factors. It sponsors the globally recognized Ikemi Award for excellence in psychosomatic medicine research.↩︎